jazz (& scrap) pages

selected jazzgoodies & off the record scrap

Nov 2

Another threat

Again, after numerous threats, I’m forced to take down a video. This time ‘Straight, No Chaser’ about Thelonious Monk has to go. 
I received mails like:

‘…Do you own this? I THINK NOT!’

‘…Do you own any of your uploads, especially Straight, No chaser? If not, you are violating international copyright law by uploading this and disgracing my dear departed friend Charlotte Zwerin…’

‘…I have notified Warner Brothers about you. You are committing a felony by uploading this…’

Since I already have a ‘Strike One’ on my YouTube channel, I take no chances.

UPDATE: When I took the video down, her reply was, and I quote:
Good.
You ought to be ASHAMED of yourself.
You NEVER should have uploaded it in the first place.
We do not live in a SOCIALIST society. Property rights are property rights.
Make your OWN movie and upload THAT. 
You people are DELUSIONAL.  
Enjoy your time in a Federal prison.
You will be “discussing” it with a Federal Judge and a District Attorney.  

[end of quote]

I’m sorry to hear that some people don’t understand the power of sharing, and how sharing ultimately benefits everyone, including the heirs of Monk and the aforementioned Zwerin.

Almost 25,000 people saw this documentary.

Perhaps 25,000 new fans.

Perhaps people who might have never heard of Monk before and went out to buy his CD’s, downloaded his music via iTunes or bought the film on DVD. 

All I want to do is ‘broadcast’ jazz to a young and new audience and try to fill them with enthusiasm for an underexposed genre.

I cannot see how that in any way can be disgracing.

Complaints can be sent to Carole Langer, the writer of the emails.


  1. consttype said: When I was 16 (20 years ago) I saw “Straight No Chaser” in a theater. I had never heard jazz before. I went out literally breathless, overwhelmed by the beauty of Monk’s music. I now own hundreds of jazz CDs, including 30 or 40 by Monk himself…
  2. sempreclaro said: After the musician passes it should become public domain.
  3. ahleuchatista said: People actually complained about the upload of those documentaries? I guess it’s not fair to stereotype jazz fans, but it still surprises me. Keep on doing what you’re doing, I respect you so much for trying to share such a great part of culture.
  4. phemeshipsborra said: I would just like to say, I saw “Straight No Chaser” for the first time on your channel. I am of the internet generation. If not for your video, I wouldn’t have seen it. You aren’t doing this for a profit; you are sharing what is relevant. Thank you.
  5. perfectcycles reblogged this from jazzpages
  6. pierreism said: Its a difficult argument to win if people are trying to protect their own copyright, but since no one who actually owns the rights contacted you in this case I would’ve ignored these complaints. Remind them you want to share, not profit from this.
  7. cleverstarck said: It’s a shame to witness such a thing happen to you. I love your blog, even though i did know Mr. Monk’s music, I have gotten to know a great deal of jazz artists through your teaching. I hope this doesn’t afflict you or your blog… Keep it going!!!
  8. ghostwithabogner reblogged this from jazzpages
  9. independentassortment said: I don’t understand people that thank this way. I agree, sharing of information benefits everyone. I guess there is just not much you can do.
  10. bellyheart said: Weird, I posted it on my account several months ago in hopes of finding out a certain song on it. People…what do they get out of that kind of stuff…trained monkeys
  11. randomberlinchick said: I will definitely send her an email. She is totally missing the point about what you are doing. Hang in there!!
  12. jazzpages posted this